Value of Old Five Dollar Bills
We have been strictly collecting and dealing with old paper money for over 25 years. Our guide is by far the most extensive price guide on the internet providing you the knowledge to avoid selling your collection too cheap. We are always looking to buy old paper money and we would be happy to answer any value or appraisal questions you may have.
we’ve paid as low as
most are worth
we’ve paid as much as
Our five dollar bill price guide covers the history of the $5 bill between the years 1863 to 1923. The year of your banknote is important as many designs look similar from year to year.
Different years may come with different serial number colors and seal types. Please contact us directly if you’re interested in knowing the value of your $5 bank note or if you are looking to sell.
In this guide, you will:
Know how much an old $5 bill is worth, see pictures of what a real $5 looks like, know when the $5 bill was discontinued and taken out of circulation, where you can sell vintage $5 bills, and where you can purchase old $5 bills.
It’s clear that antique $5 bills can be worth more than a dollar, oftentimes much, much more. Condition matters when determining any collectible currencies’ value. The goal of this page is to help you figure out what you have in your collection, and how much its really worth.
We’ve been dealing and collecting with collectible paper money for over 25 years and consider ourselves to be the strongest buyers across the entire United States.
While we are particularly specialized in high denomination bank notes, ($500, $1,000, $5,000, & $10,000 … yes they exist!) we have a strong understanding of market values for all types of paper money. Whether your bill has a red seal (Legal Tender), blue seal (Silver Certificate), gold seal (Gold Certificate), or green seal (Federal Reserve Note) we are here to help make sure you become educated about high denomination paper money.
With all this being said, you may still be unsure of how to get started. We know from a fresh perspective these concepts and “currency lingo” can be a little intimidating at first, and that’s why we’ve created this guide.
Disclaimer: Do not fall victim to selling your valuable collection to a local pawn or coin shop that will rob for what your paper money is really worth. Contact a paper money expert before selling any currency you own.
Every $5 Bill
History of your $5 Bill
Before we begin, it’s important to have a basic understanding of the factors which determine the value of your $5 bill. To get the most money for your vintage five dollar bill, if you’re like me, you’ll want to educate yourself a little bit before.
If you don’t want to spend the time, you can always send us a picture of your bill and we’ll give you an exact value. Info@RareMoneyValues.com
On top of that, I’m a huge history nerd… I completely nerd-out when it comes to the history behind old paper money. I truly love what I do.
If you’ve seen the hit television show on the History Channel, Pawn Stars, then you may have seen an old five dollar bill like these before.
We’ve been fortunate enough to work closely with this popular shop’s currency department for years now, buying and selling collectible paper money with them.
This guide doesn’t show every single $5 bill ever issued, simply because there are some exotic five dollar bills that don’t exist in public hands.
If you’re unsure what you have, feel free to contact us, we’re happy to tell you what you have.
The First United States $5 Bill
The first $5 bill ever printed was on May 10th, 1775 during the Colonial Period.
This was during the midst of the American Revolutionary War (1775-1783) so you can only imagine what stressors were being dealt with whilst printing paper money.
After colonial and continental currency came the Confederacy and their paper money bills. The first confederate $5 bill was printed by the U.S. in 1861 issued in Richmond, Virginia.
Interestingly enough, the Confederate States of America printed much higher denomination paper money before the $5 bill, in 1861.
After the Civil War, many people destroyed Confederate Currency because it essentially had no value. However, some people saved them, which is why they’re so scarce today.
Old five dollar Confederate notes are relatively easy to obtain, especially in poor quality.
If you have something similar to what’s pictured above, your bill may be fake. Counterfeiters during the Confederacy were a dime-a-dozen. The ability to fake one of these bills was easy. A lot of what we see today is modern replica money.
Fake notes look pretty obviously fake, but we’ll get more into spotting fakes a bit later in this post. If you’re uncertain, contact us and we’ll tell you if your old $5 bill is real or fake.
The transition from Confederacy into the more organized U.S. Treasury system you can see security features were put into place to deter the low barrier of entry into counterfeiting.
According to the U.S. Currency Education Program, “all currency issued since 1861 remains valid and redeemable at full face value.”
There were two types of bills printed close to 1861 which were the $5 national bank notes, printed and delivered to individual national banks around the U.S. and also 1862 & 1863 $5 Legal Tender Notes.
The “original” series $5 national bank notes are quite unique and values can range dramatically depending upon which bank issued them.
If you want to find more information about national bank notes, see this informative page where we list over 13,000 banks across the United States.
In some instances, we’ve paid over $50,000 for an old $5 bill like the five pictured above. It really comes down to a number of factors like condition, serial number, type, and place of issue.
Feel free to reach out to us if you are interested in selling your old currency. Info@RareMoneyValues.com
During this same time period, $5 legal tender bills were also printed. These bills are the closest to confederate notes as you’ll ever see.
The paper is thin, the security features are limited (see the red seal and green ink in the picture above to see what I’m talking about).
But this was a huge step in the right direction to deter counterfeiting and make it that much harder to accomplish.
Legal tender $5 bills from 1869, also known as Rainbow Notes, are some of my favorite bills to collect from the series, simply because they’re so attractive.
The Federal Reserve focused heavily on increasing its security features by adding multiple colors and also adding fibers and partially blue paper.
The reason these rainbow notes are so popular is simply due to their stunning color. The red, blue, and green are usually vibrant and make for an exceptional conversation piece.
These five dollar legal tender rainbow notes generally cost between $300 for decent condition and better condition for around $800. We’ve paid over $1,900 for especially high-grade examples of this note.
If you have a legal tender note and want a full price guide, check out this page we wrote for a more in-depth look.
The image above is a real Small Size antique $5 Legal Tender bill. Between 1869 and 1880 there are multiple different types of $5 bills.
Below I will list every type, but in this brief history breakdown, I decided to skip them for now.
As you can see above the $5 1880 dollar bill has a large brown seal to the right. This specific design is seen as late as 1917 shortly before they stopped issuing large size dollar bills.
Next came the 1890 $5 Treasury “Thomas” Note. This bill also comes with a small red seal for the 1891 date, unlike the large brown seal pictured above. Treasury notes were only printed in 1890 and 1891.
Almost all large size currency bills from the 1800s have taken on a nickname in the collector community.
The 1890 and 1891 Treasury notes have simply been nicknamed “Thomas” notes due to the person on the bill. George H. Thomas is the bearded man centered on the bill.
Five dollar silver certificates from 1891 are very popular among collectors. Virtually no fake $5 1891 notes exist, so the likelihood of you having a real bill is high.
We would love to see what you have, contact us by email, text, or phone today.
The value of 1891 five dollar silver certificates is based solely upon condition. These bills are often worth $500. However, we have paid over $1,500 for higher-grade examples.
The 1896 $5 Silver Certificate “Educational” series of notes is one of the more popular among collectors due to its depiction.
To learn more about five dollar educational notes, you can visit this value guide we wrote here.
Speaking of popular notes, 1899 $5 Silver Certificate notes, also known as “Chief” notes by collectors, have the only Chief Indian “One Papa” located at the center of each bill.
Silver certificate notes were tradable in silver at local banks. This means you could take your old $5 silver certificate bill and exchange it for exactly five dollar in silver at the time.
Quick tip: these bills are legal tender, meaning you can bring them to the bank and get $5 cash. Five dollar notes, in better condition, have collector value and bring much more than their face value.
The last type of $5 bill we wanted to share was the issue 1928 Red Seal Legal Tender Note. The five dollar red seal 1928 note is a small size bill, meaning its the same size as today’s money.
Old bills with unique serial numbers, like the five pictured above, will bring a higher premium in the marketplace. Serial number 1 notes almost always cost more money to buy.
If you want to learn more about rare serial numbers, check out this page we wrote all fancy unique serial numbers.
If you don’t see your bill pictured above, make sure to scroll through to see the rest of the five dollar bills printed by the United States.
Find Your Old Five Dollar Bill
Is My Five Dollar Bill Fake?
Good news, I’ll start by saying your $5 bill is likely real. If it’s fake, it’s worth $0. We’ve handled literally tens of thousands of old vintage $5 bills.
We have seen nearly every single fake counterfeit $5 bill under the sun. For us, they are pretty easy to point out, even from images over a computer screen.
We have worked for and with some of the best counterfeit paper money detecting experts in the industry for decades.
While it may be second nature for us to spot them out, we wanted to take some time and put together this guide to help you spot fake $5 bills and better educate yourself.
If your $5 bill is any/all of the following, your bill is fake:
- It’s laminated
- It’s black/white
- It feels like printer paper
- It’s smaller than paper money today
- It’s much bigger than paper money today
This is also one of the main reasons why the United States stopped printing $5 dollar bills, they didn’t want people to counterfeit them. This goes for any country in the world today that still prints paper money.
Five dollar bills are some of the least counterfeited money in the world. Why fake a $5 bill when you can multiply and fake a $100? The idea is the bigger you make the money, the easier it is to transport large quantities without detection.
$5 bills from 1900 and earlier have a higher chance of being a forgery. If you need help please send us a picture and we’d gladly determine the authenticity of your old $5 bill.
Selling your $5 Bill
Step 1: Send Us A Picture
Step 2: Receive Our Offer
Step 3: Get Paid
An old $5 bill has been given to you from a friend or passed down from a family member and you don’t really care to keep it. You’d much rather have money in your bank account.
The absolute worst thing you could do is bring your $5 bill to a local bank. They will give you its face value of $5. The reality is some antique five dollar bills can be with up to $55,000 or more.
Find a Paper Money Expert
Paper money experts are different than your typical local Pawn or Coin shop.
Most experts are collectors themselves and truly love the hobby as a whole. Almost all local shops are almost required to rip-off the people they’re buying from. They do it in order to pay for renting a big building and having multiple employees.
I’ve been collecting coins and paper money almost my entire life. I have a secured, private office where I deal only with certain customers after setting up an appointment. I don’t have a walk-in, public shop. We have low overhead costs which allow us to pay top dollar for high denomination paper money. If you ever want to meet for a local deal, we are located in Boca Raton, FL.
Safely Shipping your $5 Bill
We insure all packages that come in and go out of our office. If you follow our easy shipping and packing instructions and the package somehow gets lost in the mail, no worries, our insurance will cover it.
Payment is sent via PayPal or checks when you sell your high denomination $5 bills to us. Once we receive the package we verify the banknotes and send your payment the same or next day. We have satisfied thousands of customers who have shipped us their $5 bills.
Rare Money Values
4.9/5 ★★★★★ 5 Reviews
Verified Customer Reviews
TRUST TRUST TRUST! Do not hesitate to trust Marc. I had no references, no affiliation and nothing to go off of, I found Marc through google and proceeded to communicate via his easy to follow website. He was almost immediate with response time, as well as completely transparent, he also exceeded all prior offers I had received on my notes. Marc is a refreshing professional, I hope to do business again soon. A+ from start to finish.
Marc is a true expert and is real top-notch. I was somewhat worried about shipping my currency to him but he assured me everything would be OK. And it was lol. There is no risk when I sell my money here because I know I'm getting the full value of my collection.
Very pleasant experience. Been selling old money to Marc for 10 years would recommend.
Marc Michaelsen is very friendly and helpful. He helped determine the value of my currency collection and the best way to go about selling it! Rare money values has a large wealth of information regarding $500 bills. Marc gave me more money for my $500 bill than I could have got anywhere locally. It was a pleasure dealing with you and will come back to you for any other currency-related sales.
So I was given a large paper money collection from my grandfather and had no idea what to do with it. I researched online and found this website. I contacted Marc and he made the whole thing really easy. Thank you for everything.
We get hundreds of frequently asked questions each week via calls, emails, and text messages.
Before contacting us, we wanted to answer any basic questions you have about your high denomination $5 bill.
If you don’t see your question below or are interested in selling your $5 note to us, feel free to contact us today.
Commonly Asked Questions About Old $5 Bills:
Who Is Pictured On The $5 Bill?: It depends. Most five dollar bills, both large and small size currency, will have Abraham Lincoln on them. However, some old $5 bills have Andrew Jackson, Indian Chief “One Papa”, James A Garfield, or Allegorical Figures.
Why Don’t I See My $5 Bill In Your Price Guide?: Our price guide only shows the more common $5 bills that most people encounter. We aren’t including some $5 large size proof bills in this guide due to their extreme rarity.
If you have a five dollar bill that’s not pictured in our guide, we highly recommend sending us a picture of it. That is the only way we’re able to identify and determine its value for you.
What Is An Error $5 Bill Worth?: Misprinted, or error, $5 bills are extremely scarce and when they do appear, the errors are super minor. Some errors like inverted backs, meaning the back is upside down, or missing seals, missing serial numbers, inverted seals, inverted stars, these can all bring a large premium with currency collectors we deal with.
What Is A Five Dollar Bill Star Note?: In short, they’re $5 bills that have a star symbol instead of the letter A at the end of the serial number. These bills have a bigger premium over the regularly issued antique $5 bills. Star notes are scarce, especially from series 1928 and earlier
What Is The Most Common Large Size $5 Bill?: Large size $5 bills aren’t common, to begin with, but you are most likely to see 1907 $5 legal tenders and 1914 $5 blue seal federal reserve notes. The value of these can be as little as $35. Better graded examples can bring $500 or more. Contact us with a picture if you need help determining the value of your $5 bill.
How Much Does A $5 Bill Cost?: This is a tough question because we’ve paid $15 for some common five dollar bills. Some are only worth $5 if they’re in very poor condition. In very rare instances your $5 bill could be worth over $55,000. It depends upon multiple factors including condition, issuing district, eye appeal, market demand, scarce varieties, and more.
Can I Get An Old $5 Bill From The Bank?: Yes. The chances you get a red seal legal tender, blue seal silver certificate, or yellow seal gold certificate, is slim to none. The reason being most of these will catch a bank teller’s eye and they’ll get taken out of circulation.
How Do I Know My $5 Is Real?: We touched on forgery $5 bills earlier in the guide. Essentially there are multiple factors that help determine the authenticity of your $5 bill. To learn more, find the section above that talks more in-depth about counterfeit $5s.
Why Doesn’t The U.S. Print Large Size $5 Bills Anymore?: Large size paper money wasn’t practical to be printed and handled by consumers. Small size five dollar bills fit easily in your pockets and also used less paper and ink, which means less cost.
If you look at the paper money from around the world, you’ll see they’re leaps and bounds above the U.S. in terms of artwork and open-mindedness with their design.
What Do Counterfeit $5 Bills Look Like?: $5 bills that are black/white, laminated, smaller than typical paper money today, much larger than typical paper money today, are all going to be fake. If it’s too good to be true, it probably is. Please send us a picture if you want your $5 bill to be authenticated.
What Is The Most Expensive Five Dollar Bills?: There are only a few $5 bills that have sold for over $55,000 dollars. Keep your expectations low because the chance you have one of these bills is one in a million. Your typical five dollar bill will cost you about $5. Most people think they have something extremely rare, unfortunately, most of the time its a very common note. However, there are always exceptions. Contact us for more information.
We Are Buyers
Raremoneyvalues.com is the most competitive old $5 bill purchasing website in the United States. We’ve purchased tens of thousands of old five dollar bills during our time collecting and dealing with paper currency. Please contact us today if you’re interested in selling your old collection or need help authenticating your rare paper money.